Loneliness looks popular these days
Americans, who shocked pollsters in 1985 when they said they had
only three close friends, today say they have just two. The number
who say they have no one to discuss important matters with has doubled
to 25 percent, according to a nationwide survey to be released today.
It found that men and women of every race, age and education level reported
fewer intimate friends than the same survey turned up in 1985. Their remaining
confidants were more likely to be members of their nuclear family than in 1985,
according to the study, but intimacy within families was down, too. The findings
will be reported in the June issue of the American Sociological Review.
Weakening bonds of friendship, which other studies affirm, have far-reaching
effects. Among them: fewer people to turn to for help, fewer watchdogs to deter
neighborhood crime, fewer visitors for hospital patients and fewer participants
in community groups. The decline, which was greatest in estimates of the number
of friends outside the family, also puts added pressure on spouses, families and
counselors.
“People are isolated in their own families,” said Laurie Thorner, a therapist
in Annapolis, Md., since the 1980s. “I definitely agree that there's less
support for people.”
Study co-author Lynn Smith-Lovin, a sociologist at Duke University, called
the sharp declines startling, and added, “You don't usually expect major
features of social life to change very much from year to year or even decade to
decade.”
One explanation for friendship's decline is that adults are working longer
hours and socializing less. In addition, commutes are longer, and TV viewing and
computer use are up.
As connections to neighbors and social clubs decline, Smith-Lovin said, “It
means you've got more people isolated in a small network of people who are just
like them.”
She speculated that social isolation may have made Hurricane Katrina worse.
“The people we saw sitting on roofs after Katrina hit were probably people
without close ties to someone with a car to get them out,” she said.
She's right, said Bob Howard, spokesman for the American Red Cross' Hurricane
Relief Project.
“People that had friends and family were probably most likely to evacuate,”
he said.
Even before Katrina, Red Cross volunteering – an effort for which friends
often are recruiters and in which friendships sustain membership – was way off,
spokeswoman Marietta Basel said. It's down from 1.3 million volunteers in 1996
to 820,000 last year. It's a time problem, according to Basel. “People don't
have time to volunteer in a registered fashion and agree to volunteer X number
of hours a week.”
Robert Putnam, the author of “Bowling Alone,” the 2000 best-selling book on
America's declining civic life, said his more recent research generally tracked
the findings of Smith-Lovin and Miller McPherson, a sociologist at the
University of Arizona.
“We would actually think that the trends have leveled off a little bit” since
2000, but not reversed, said Putnam, who teaches public policy at Harvard
University.
People pay a price when bonds of friendship weaken, he continued.
“Communities that have tighter social networks have lower crime and lower
mortality and less corruption and more effective government and less tax
evasion.”
The study also showed that the size of social networks is linked to a
person's educational level and race. Non-whites tend to have smaller networks
than whites. Black men older than 60, in particular, have seen their circles
shrink from an average of 3.8 in 1985 to 1.8 in 2004, the survey showed.
People with more education also have larger networks than people with less
education, although the number of contacts has declined for college-educated
people.
The study's findings are based on questions that were added to one of the
nation's classic attitude polls, the General Social Survey, which the University
of Chicago's National Opinion Research Center has conducted every two years
since 1972.
The face-to-face survey of 1,467 people over 18 also found that the
percentage of people who say they only talk to family members about important
matters has risen from 57 percent to nearly 80 percent, while the number of
people who say they depend totally on their spouse has gone from 5 percent to
nearly 9 percent.